Mar 11, 2011

Book Review: "Jean Arthur: The actress nobody knew" by John Oller


How many interviews from Miss Arthur have you seen? How many special appearances? How many candid pictures? If you're lucky, very few, right? Before I read this biography, I didn't know a thing about Jean's life. I just loved her movies and the positiveness she managed to transmit 80 years later. It was weird I didn't know much about her: if you're subscribed to more than a hundred classic movie blogs, you always get to know a bit about performers. But this is not the case. What happened is that Gladys Green's life turned out to be even more mysterious than Garbo's, and that's saying a lot ("I like to think I understand Garbo a little. Her seclusion. Her refusal to talk for publication. Her belief that only her work is important to her public. I feel that way too")

I think that the reclusive life of the Swedish actress has always been a popular subject, that everyone tried to unveil by contributing with anecdotes and memories. Even in this biography is told the one awkward time Miss Arthur and Miss Garbo met. But again, that's not Jean's case. Miss Arthur was most of the times facing her own demons at home, away from everything and everyone, loving acting but fearing the failure and losing her beloved freedom.

John Oller invites you to try understand what was going on in the mind of one of the most talented screwball actresses, the woman that some say suffered from a inferiority complex, the girl with the husky voice that was funny in her own, clever way. The author's research is impressive: he managed to contact important sources such as Jean's best friends, fellow actors in the few plays she did, relatives and even people like her ex husband's barber. Besides these interesting quotes, there are other sources, that in Jean's case are very rare: passages from the few interviews to different newspapers she gave during her career.

Jean, about 6, photographed by her dad.
"I can't seem to be able to the things grown up people do. I can't go to parties. When I do go, it's because I force myself to go, because Frank, my husband, wants me to go, thinks I should go for my own good. Sometimes I have fun when I actually get to a place. More often, I don't. I suffer". Well, that's the Jean you manage to know a bit more by reading this book, speaking. She was definitely an interesting and very complex human being. She loved nature, she loved philosophy, she loved reading, she loved freedom to do whatever she wanted to do, she loved classic music and talking with interesting people when she wanted to. And most of all she loved the perenne figures of Peter Pan and Jeanne D'Arc. She hated aging. She hated interviews, she hated being a celebrity and the associated business like posing for stills, she hated being pushed and pressured, she hated conservatism, she hated the spotlight.

And you learn all this by reading the story of Gladys Green, from her childhood in which her father, a photographer, could carefully portray her smiling under the trees and years later abandon his family; to the days in which she left Hollywood and entered to university after divorcing her husband; then her bittersweet experiences on stage and TV; and finally the days in which her quiet life was disturbed only by invitations to ceremonies to honor people like Frank Capra, a few reporters trying to get a story or dogs being mistreated (you'll have to get the book).

Of course you also learn a lot about Hollywood: her brief relationship with David Selznick, how she met Norma Shearer before they went to the capital of films, her early movies with William Powell, her battles with Harry Cohn and how she was banned by the studio for not agreeing to play stupid characters, her part in the "Scarlett O'Hara war", how she independently produced with her husband The Devil and Miss Jones, her successes, her failures, actors she liked (and secretly loved like Gary Cooper) and people she didn't get along with very well (for example...Cary Grant). Of course, don't expect the book to end with her departure from Hollywood and then a fast wrap-up, no, when you reach that point there are still several interesting chapters to read.

Jean never told her real age. It was impressive to learn that after a decade of struggling to get a decent role in Hollywood and finally succeed with "The whole town is talking" and then with "Mr. Deeds goes to town" she had already blown out the candles on more than 34 cakes! 

Jean Arthur (on the ground) as Peter Pan. She was 50.

And you learn about her dreams, like portraying her heroes, Peter Pan and Jeanne D'Arc (now you know from whom she took her stage name). She enjoyed real success when she played the first in theater, the media and the assistants loved her acting, but her demons pushed her away after some weeks. And they didn't even let her present the second. I think it's sad she never managed to truly fulfill her dreams. Her mind and her body just couldn't stand so much pressure.

Even when there are some points that are not really clear (why she never had children for example) it's not because of lack of research, but because there are not records of Jean, the main source, discussing such a private matter. In cases like this, Oller confronts opinions of relatives, passages of Jean's life and even psychological theories to try to give explanations and let you decide what to think. My only problem with the book is technical: the printing is wrong so the bottom margin is really wide and the top is too narrow. It's completely readable anyway, but be careful!

This book was really a surprise and I just couldn't stop reading. This is one of the best biographies I've ever read and I really feel I know Jean a bit more. When you're discussing a private person like her, "a bit" is a lot.

"She and the composer [Leonard Bernstein] became fast friends. He wrote the jaunty little "Shadow Dance" number for her, which she played over and over on the phonograph in her hotel room, working out her choreography". So, let me finish with Shadow Dance from the Peter Pan play, which I think captures Jean Arthur's own free spirit, the one she protected her whole life:




 Youtube Alert! 


 More Book Review

14 comments:

  1. Clara,

    This was such an interesting read! Admittedly I don't know a lot about Jean's life outside of the pictures so this book sounds like a must have. I loved Jean in all of her films but especially "Mr. Smith Goes to Washington" and "Easy Living".

    Thanks to this delightful post I'll be adding her biography to my book list now. : )

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great post -- I am a fan of Jean Arthur's movies, but didn't know much about her as a person other than that she had stage fright and that she retired pretty early, but no details. Sounds like an interesting book, one I should look for. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  3. this is one of my favorite biographies as well! and this is an excellent write up. that dog story from the beginning will always stick with me. It has been awhile since I read it but the only thing that seemed like a stretch to me (because as I recall it wasn't substantiated with commentary from those who knew her, etc, the way many of his other points were) was the assertion that she only went in front of the cameras to please her father. Despite his photography background and the fact that I would imagine it is psychologically devastating when your father walks out it didn't quite mesh with the way he laid out his other points. An interesting thought nonetheless.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Page: Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed my post, and yes, I really recommend this book to you, I hope you like it as I did :)

    MM: Thanks, yes, it's a really interesting book on a very interesting person :)

    Meredith: Yeah, you're right on that, I didn't remember that point. The thing is that while I was reading it, it seemed natural that a daughter of a photographer would work posing for photographs. And everyone wanted to go to Hollywood back then, so if she was photogenic all the more reason to go there and give it a try. Thanks for sharing your opinion, I really appreciate it :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. That was a great read, and very touching, Clara!

    I am always happy if people help to make Jean a bit more famous again, so the big movie companies might re-release some more of her films.

    Anyway the world won't be a worse place if her mostly very sweet and kind film characters spread their positively unique mood all over our modern world.

    I love your review!
    Clarissa

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you, Clarissa, I'm glad you liked it, being such a Jean Arthur fan and all :) I agree with everything you said about Jean of course, and I hope she gets even more recognition, she deserves it :) Oh, thanks for following!!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Clara,

    Hello I'm John Oller, author of the book. Thank you for mentioning it and for your favorable comments, glad you and others enjoyed it.

    best,

    John Oller

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi John,

    well your visit and comment is a bit unexpected, but thank YOU for your very professional work. You really help me to understand a bit more mysterious Jean Arthur. I'd love to ask you a some questions about your personal process while writing the book.

    Thank you very much for stopping by :)

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thank you, Clarissa, I'm glad you liked it, being such a Jean Arthur fan and all :) I agree with everything you said about Jean of course, and I hope she gets even more recognition, she deserves it :) Oh, thanks for following!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Clara,

    Hello I'm John Oller, author of the book. Thank you for mentioning it and for your favorable comments, glad you and others enjoyed it.

    best,

    John Oller

    ReplyDelete
  11. Great post -- I am a fan of Jean Arthur's movies, but didn't know much about her as a person other than that she had stage fright and that she retired pretty early, but no details. Sounds like an interesting book, one I should look for. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
  12. this is one of my favorite biographies as well! and this is an excellent write up. that dog story from the beginning will always stick with me. It has been awhile since I read it but the only thing that seemed like a stretch to me (because as I recall it wasn't substantiated with commentary from those who knew her, etc, the way many of his other points were) was the assertion that she only went in front of the cameras to please her father. Despite his photography background and the fact that I would imagine it is psychologically devastating when your father walks out it didn't quite mesh with the way he laid out his other points. An interesting thought nonetheless.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Clara,

    This was such an interesting read! Admittedly I don't know a lot about Jean's life outside of the pictures so this book sounds like a must have. I loved Jean in all of her films but especially "Mr. Smith Goes to Washington" and "Easy Living".

    Thanks to this delightful post I'll be adding her biography to my book list now. : )

    ReplyDelete
  14. That was a great read, and very touching, Clara!

    I am always happy if people help to make Jean a bit more famous again, so the big movie companies might re-release some more of her films.

    Anyway the world won't be a worse place if her mostly very sweet and kind film characters spread their positively unique mood all over our modern world.

    I love your review!
    Clarissa

    ReplyDelete

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...